• Our new ticketing site is now live! Using either this or the original site (both powered by TrainSplit) helps support the running of the forum with every ticket purchase! Find out more and ask any questions/give us feedback in this thread!

CAF class 197 Civity for TfW: News and updates on introduction.

Topological

Established Member
Joined
20 Feb 2023
Messages
4,296
Location
Swansea
Manchester is supposed to be a 2 + 3 arrangement.

Since at the moment we only have almost 2 on most services the 197s are going to be very welcome.
 
Sponsor Post - registered members do not see these adverts; click here to register, or click here to log in
R

RailUK Forums

TT-ONR-NRN

Veteran Member
Joined
30 Dec 2016
Messages
12,833
Location
Cambridge
Manchester is supposed to be a 2 + 3 arrangement.

Since at the moment we only have almost 2 on most services the 197s are going to be very welcome.
Yes, the only 2 car will be the half eight from Manchester each evening. I certainly am not going to complain about that seeing as how many there are now, although I do note the rather unfortunate irony in that that's the very train I usually get when I've been to Manchester :lol::rolleyes:

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

I think whether or not TfW are able to deliver the promised double formations as booked (and that's all on the Shrewsbury Cardiff corridor except two very late in the evening) will have a major impact on how these trains are perceived by customers in Mid and South Wales.

Run them in the booked 4 and 5 carriage formations, and people will start to associate their new trains with having more space and a better chance of getting a seat compared to before their introduction.

Run them solo, and people will immediately start to resent the new trains for being overcrowded, cramped, and there's a good deal it'll probably make them notice other things too, like seat comfort (should they dislike the Sophias) or drafts from the doors, as one tends to notice the negatives in something more when they've already got a major bone to pick with it.
 

Jez

Established Member
Joined
22 Jan 2011
Messages
2,326
Location
Neath
It won’t look good if they only send 2 cars & they are packed. People will say look - TfW have replaced rammed 2 car trains with new rammed 2 car trains. They need to provide the new 197’s with the right number of carriages to fit the predicted loadings for that diagram.

I think that's pretty understandable since Manchester is much bigger of a destination, the 3 (or 6 if doubled?) car 197s
Manchester's are supposed to be 5 cars when the full 197 service starts

Yes Manchester a much bigger destination although many people travel to Cardiff from the likes of Hereford, Abergavenny and Cwmbran too which would also be served by the Holyheads.

The full 197 service on the West Wales/Cardiff/Manchester/North Wales services cant come soon enough.

== Doublepost prevention - post automatically merged: ==

It won’t look good if they only send 2 cars & they are packed. People will say look - TfW have replaced rammed 2 car trains with new rammed 2 car trains. They need to provide the new 197’s with the right number of carriages to fit the predicted loadings for that diagram.
It might not look good but if 2 cars are all that is available that is all we will get. And a 2 car 197 is a massive improvement on a 150/158/pair of 153s. In my opinion of course.
 

Techniquest

Veteran Member
Joined
19 Jun 2005
Messages
21,834
Location
Nowhere Heath
Do we know how many 197s are typically allocated on a day to passenger and training, compared to how many TfW have?
Hopefully it can be a double on North-South (I assume that fits since MK4s run that route, also don't Civities have SDO?)

Not a clue!

These tend to arrive at Cardiff far more packed than the ex Holyheads too, and also leave much busier.

Very true, one of TfW's busiest routes after all! I'll just be glad to see the 197s down here, a good run on one is long overdue!
 

Nick Ashwell

Member
Joined
20 Dec 2018
Messages
463
Very true, one of TfW's busiest routes after all! I'll just be glad to see the 197s down here, a good run on one is long overdue!
Plus anything that frees up stock so the Cheltenhams aren't using single unit 153s like Tuesday is a massive benefit!
 

Nick Ashwell

Member
Joined
20 Dec 2018
Messages
463
Not sending trains off lease might do that...

It is just like it is accepted that TfW keep doing that.
I agree but I also accept that the lease terms were agreed prior to any delays in new stock, although not tying down the 170s to their original plans is a travesty which leads to the long term keeping of 153s, even if they may make more sense for HoW they don't add flexibility. We've had one 175 a day recently which helps, I'm thinking another 170 has been sent away but not seen that for a fact? Not seeing the Ebbw Vale roster means commenting too much would likely make me look a tool
 

sd0733

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2012
Messages
5,186
Not sending trains off lease might do that...

It is just like it is accepted that TfW keep doing that.
There's an end date on the lease where they all have to be back, the leasing company haven't extended it so they can't just be held onto.

There's been some progress with the ongoing issues with acceptance so a date fairly soon (this month) is being worked to where a whole batch of units should be accepted.
 

pokemonsuper9

Established Member
Joined
20 Dec 2022
Messages
4,612
Location
Greater Manchester
Manchester's are supposed to be 5 cars when the full 197 service starts
Do TfW have any set plan for where they want First Class to be, like how most London TOCs aim towards London?
I'd say have First Class facing Manchester since at Piccadilly that'd be most convenient for the passengers there, but I'm not good with Welsh stations so not fully sure on where First Class would fit best (Would middle of the train be better for most stations, I think it'd work better for Cardiff?)
 

Topological

Established Member
Joined
20 Feb 2023
Messages
4,296
Location
Swansea
Do TfW have any set plan for where they want First Class to be, like how most London TOCs aim towards London?
I'd say have First Class facing Manchester since at Piccadilly that'd be most convenient for the passengers there, but I'm not good with Welsh stations so not fully sure on where First Class would fit best (Would middle of the train be better for most stations, I think it'd work better for Cardiff?)
Is it just Manchester, Swansea and Carmarthen which are the progressively less well served dead end stations on the route? The various branch termini may not actually have their exits at one end.

it is going to be interesting with 5 car trains. In theory the 3 is at the Swansea end so that the 2 can be detached?
 

sd0733

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2012
Messages
5,186
Well in that case First Class would either have to be in the Front or Middle (relative to a passenger at Piccadilly).
It's likely to just end up where it does, there's too many places that end up turning sets (Chester, Manchester via Warrington, Carmarthen, Swansea) to be consistent.
It's not even certain yet it'll operate yet on the 197s for a variety of reasons.
 

pokemonsuper9

Established Member
Joined
20 Dec 2022
Messages
4,612
Location
Greater Manchester
It's likely to just end up where it does, there's too many places that end up turning sets (Chester, Manchester via Warrington, Carmarthen, Swansea) to be consistent.
Aren't the 1st class ones only for Manchester - South Wales via Stockport, Crewe and Shrewsbury?
And I don't think many TfW trains skip Carmarthen and Swansea so they'd just always end up turning there and stay the way they were left.
 

Caaardiff

Established Member
Joined
9 Jun 2019
Messages
1,382
Do TfW have any set plan for where they want First Class to be, like how most London TOCs aim towards London?
I'd say have First Class facing Manchester since at Piccadilly that'd be most convenient for the passengers there, but I'm not good with Welsh stations so not fully sure on where First Class would fit best (Would middle of the train be better for most stations, I think it'd work better for Cardiff?)
It's difficult to tell because of the network TFW work on. Don't forget that the 197's will be maintained at Chester, even though predominantly working South Wales - Manchester (unconfirmed if any other routes). The route to Chester is either via Wrexham or via Crewe, meaning whichever way it arrives will be opposite to the other when arriving into Chester.
Occasionally services run to Carmarthen via Landore/District, without calling at Swansea where it would turn. Occasionally for engineering services turn at east usk when coming off the marches line.
I think the original plan with the mk4's were to keep the loco on a certain end, but that went out of the window within the first week.

Ultimately the 3 car needs to be leading from Manchester into Swansea to detach the 2 car for Milford Haven.
Also some platforms aren't long enough for 5 car trains, so with ASDO, if First is right at the front or the rear of the 3 car train, at some point it will be right at the back and people will need to walk through.
 

OrangeJuice

Member
Joined
4 Jun 2018
Messages
210
So you can't travel first class in a wheelchair and all the catering supplies for first have to be carted through the train from the other driving car. Why isn't first class in the other driving car between the disabled area and the catering cavern?
Then it would be the same as the 185's with transpennine, but slightly worse as there would be almost no standard seats at all in one carriage. First would be either side of the catering cupboard and the wheelchair area/toilet at the end
 

tomuk

Established Member
Joined
15 May 2010
Messages
2,009
Then it would be the same as the 185's with transpennine, but slightly worse as there would be almost no standard seats at all in one carriage. First would be either side of the catering cupboard and the wheelchair area/toilet at the end
Could you not just have 12 1st class between the catering cavern and the doors leaving te saloon behind the cab as standard.
 

anthony263

Established Member
Joined
19 Aug 2008
Messages
6,892
Location
South Wales
There's an end date on the lease where they all have to be back, the leasing company haven't extended it so they can't just be held onto.

There's been some progress with the ongoing issues with acceptance so a date fairly soon (this month) is being worked to where a whole batch of units should be accepted.
Can't wait for more 197s to be accepted situation is getting worse as time drags on
 

sd0733

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2012
Messages
5,186
Looks likely that an additional diagram will be introduced tomorrow. On top of the 1st one, should be 3 different units heading to Cardiff.

Planned to be:
4-car 197
08:20 Chester to Cardiff Central
13:22 Cardiff Central to Holyhead

2-car 197
08:05 Holyhead to Cardiff Central
15:23 Cardiff Central to Holyhead.
 

Techniquest

Veteran Member
Joined
19 Jun 2005
Messages
21,834
Location
Nowhere Heath
Ho ho ho, I will have to make sure I'm up at a good hour for that 0820 from Chester then! My shift start time even works with doing it Hereford-Cardiff and back quite happily. Definitely something I'll be waiting for in the morning :)
 

SuperLuke2334

Established Member
Joined
23 Oct 2021
Messages
1,898
Location
Welsh Marches
Looks likely that an additional diagram will be introduced tomorrow. On top of the 1st one, should be 3 different units heading to Cardiff.

Planned to be:
4-car 197
08:20 Chester to Cardiff Central
13:22 Cardiff Central to Holyhead

2-car 197
08:05 Holyhead to Cardiff Central
15:23 Cardiff Central to Holyhead.
That sounds great! How they're going to do all the diagrams with only 15 accepted units though I am not sure!
 

sd0733

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2012
Messages
5,186
That sounds great! How they're going to do all the diagrams with only 15 accepted units though I am not sure!
As long as all the training runs use non accepted units it should be possible to cover the diagrams. It would make sense to ensure these diagrams run over the captive NW coast onesvi order to maintain competency of different depots.
 

SuperLuke2334

Established Member
Joined
23 Oct 2021
Messages
1,898
Location
Welsh Marches
Is there still a block on unit acceptance?
I refer you to this post:
There's an end date on the lease where they all have to be back, the leasing company haven't extended it so they can't just be held onto.

There's been some progress with the ongoing issues with acceptance so a date fairly soon (this month) is being worked to where a whole batch of units should be accepted.
 

Techniquest

Veteran Member
Joined
19 Jun 2005
Messages
21,834
Location
Nowhere Heath
Didn't spot that one! Let's hope this works out - an end to long distance sprinters may be in sight!

That day is slowly coming! Each day that passes is a day closer, and as nuts as it seems I'll kind of, sort of, miss the current era where it's been a sort-of lottery as to what turns up. However, I am absolutely looking forward to the day when it's much more reliable to know what to expect!

I'm thinking that I may have to do my North Wales train day in a few weeks' time, believe it or not I still haven't done a 150, 153 or 158 west of Saltney Junction towards Holyhead!

Before I forget to ask, does anyone know how many Holyhead services currently see 197s? I'm guessing it's mostly peak time extensions of the Manchester-Llandudno services for now?
 

sd0733

Established Member
Joined
7 Nov 2012
Messages
5,186
What's been preventing acceptance?
Various contractual issues between different parties. But its not something that anyone who knows more details will be at liberty to share on a public forum.

In the future maybe an FOI request may be the only way anyone finds out anything. Potentially could show something
 

Top